When I Saw You, I Fell In Love, Wood Sign, Wedding Gift, Wedding Decor, Anniversary Gift, Valentine's Day, Photo Prop, You Choose Colors


Shipping to United States: Free



When I Saw You I Fell In Love Wood Sign

Listing photo shown in a cream with brown lettering.


Edge Type/Board Size:
FLAT EDGE: This is the 1/2” thick edge of the wood used for the sign. There is no additional edging attached. We keyhole the back of our flat edged signs so they hang flush to the wall in a very secure manner.

BOXED EDGE: 1 3/4" boxed out edge done in wood in the same color as the face of the board. This gives the piece a canvas-look to the wooden sign. There is no keyhole or hardware on the back of the boxed out signs.

1. Clean Crisp Lettering: The sign is painted and a special finish is added. We then use vinyl for the lettering. The vinyl on this sign looks just like hand painted words on the board and gives the sign a "clean and crisp" look as the lettering is perfect. There is slight distressing on the edges.
(NOTE: OUR VINYL LETTERING DOES NOT PEEL. When the vinyl is added to our specialized finish, the vinyl becomes chemically bonded with the sign and the vinyl will become permanently attached to the sign.)

2. Distressed/vintage. The sign and the letters are painted (no vinyl) and then we distress the sign in a medium distressing. Because of the nature of wood and the nature of hand distressing, each sign will vary in its appearance. We do not try and cover any natural “flaws” in the wood as we believe this gives the sign a more naturally aged/distressed look. (If you prefer a “light” or “heavy” distressing please let us know in the notes at checkout)

Our signs are made from either a high grade plywood or mdf depending on the finish we are trying to achieve. The mdf we use is an Eco-Certified Composite and is certified as meeting the sourcing requirements for the Sustainable Forestry Initiative

We offer a variety of sizes. Please click on the drop down menu on the right hand side of the listing for our available sizes. If you need a custom size, please message me.

Paint colors are in the second listing photo. Vinyl colors are shown in the third listing photo.

During checkout, please list the following information in the notes:

1. Board color
2. Lettering color. (this will be the vinyl color for the "clean crisp" look and the paint color for the "vintage" look.)


Please message me on Etsy with any questions.
You can find more subway art boards in my shop:http://www.etsy.com/shop/vinylcrafts?section_id=8011147

Production of each sign is started once an order is placed.

See shop announcements for current production times.

If you are in need of express shipping or a rush order . . . please message me for the rates for one or both of these options.

All designs and photos owned by Vinyl Crafts, LLC: © Copyright 2010-present. All Rights Reserved. Any and all infringements of the same shall be directed to Vinyl Crafts’ legal counsel for immediate action.

Shipping from United States

Processing time

3-5 business days

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

I gladly accept returns and cancellations

Just contact me within: 7 days of delivery

Ship items back to me within: 14 days of delivery

Request a cancellation within: 24 hours of purchase

I don't accept exchanges

But please contact me if you have any problems with your order.

The following items can't be returned or exchanged

Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:

  • Custom or personalized orders

Conditions of return

Buyers are responsible for return shipping costs. If the item is not returned in its original condition, the buyer is responsible for any loss in value.

Frequently Asked Questions

Custom and personalized orders

We love doing custom and personalized orders. For custom orders, please contact me through the Etsy message system. For personalized orders, please put the information in the "notes to vinylcrafts" at the checkout screen. I will contact you with any questions I may have.

All custom and personalized items will have a digital proof sent to you prior to production. Please watch for the proof in your Etsy inbox. Production cannot begin on your order without an approved proof. This is to ensure that you are getting the exact design you want.

Once a proof is approved, if you receive the item with an error you missed during the approval, you will be responsible for the costs for a fix/replacement. Please look at your proofs carefully.

Where Do I Put My Color Preferences?

Please put the colors you want for your sign and lettering in the "notes to vinylcrafts" at the checkout screen.

If you are choosing a distressed finish, choose two colors from the paint color swatches (listing photo #2)

If you are choosing a clean, crisp finish, choose the sign color from the paint color swatches (listing photo #2) and the lettering from the vinyl color swatches (listing photo #3)

If you are unsure of your color choices, I am happy to send you a colorized digital sample showing you what different colors look like together.

Wholesale availability

We do sell wholesale. Please contact me through the Etsy message system or at becky@vinylcrafts.net for more information.

Damaged Signs

For products that arrive damaged, we require that the buyer send us a picture of the damaged product as well as the damaged packaging within 72 hours. This is necessary for claim purposes with FedEx, UPS and USPS, as well as for a replacement. After this information is received we will send out a replacement asap. 

The damaged item does not need to be returned.

How To Hang Our Signs

For our “Boxed Edge” you can hang the sign from the inside top edge, aligning two nails in the wall with the upper inside corners of the sign. Then slide the sign right onto the nails so that the upper corners rest on the nails.

For our “Flat 1/2” Edge” we keyhole the back so that the sign hangs flush to the wall.

For our framed signs, you can either use the keyholes on the back (make sure you the nails are long enough as they have to reach past the framing) OR you can hang them from the inside top edge of the frame, aligning two nails in the wall with the upper inside corners of the framing.

We recommend that you use wall anchors no matter the method you use to hang our signs.

Reviews (4)


It's exactly what I pictured! Packaged beautifully too!

Perfect! Love the quote and nice craftsmanship. Seller was very helpful and accommodating when one sign had a small flaw. Will shop again!!

Exactly as described! Becky was so sweet and helpful with picking out the design I needed. I ordered two wooden signs for my upcoming wedding which arrived on time and just as discussed! Thank you so much!

Legal imprint